wows! my dd is 7 in yr3 here, just got above averages in his sats, and is being taught in a group of high acheivers, but i doubt he would have done that! to be fair that shows some pretty logical intelligent thinking and i agree really maybe marking his wrong isnt entirely fair? wow you really got me thinking on this one now. he did get the question wrong in fairness but it shows a different level of thinking going on that should be recognised mmmm interesting!