Anyone else have a no-santa Christmas?

stayawake

stayawake

New member
I think I'm the only person I've met who has decided to NOT teach their children about Santa, and while I'm really happy with this decison, it's a little tricky when I'm out and other kids are around. I was just wondering if anyone else has a Christmas like mine?

I love that our December is really full of lots of fun, but my daughter isn't constantly talking about what Santa will bring her. She'll get lots of gifts, but she doesn't really care what they are. There is no need to remind my children of the 'true meaning of Christmas' because while presents are involved we do a lot of giving to others, serving others and making things for others -as well as attend many events at our church. My husband and I both made this decision before we had kids, and I couldn't go back now! My daughter (3) thinks 'Santas' are just like snowmen - something that shows up around this time of year. And we've begun talking to her about St. Nicolas, who did kind things for others and gave to the poor at this time of year - but it's not a real live creature that's coming to our house or anything. I had one mom at a playgroup tell me I'm ruining Christmas for my kids, and another who said ' oh, you must be one of those religious fanatics' when I said 'we don't really do that' when she asked if I had taken the kids to see Santa. What do you think?
 
we don't do santa here either :) I didnt' as a kid.. I don't really see the need. However, LOL... ce has just started realizing "who" santa is c/o the tv.. he thinks he's just like a tv character though.. it kinda makes me giggle. I remember being in 3rd grade and being really mean to the kids who believed in santa.. I hope ce isn't like that.
 
oh and I get the whole.. "you're ruining things" for your kid all the time.. esp since we don't do halloween either. ^_^ once again.. never did as a kid.. and I'm just fine thx. lol
 
I wanted a no Santa life, DH wanted some Santa, so we kind of combined it. We celebrate Jesus' birthday on Christmas, and Santa is like a clown you invite to the party to entertain :)

He puts little presents in the stockings and he's around, but the main focus for the holiday is to celebrate the birth of Christ.

And don't worry about what other parents think of how you're doing it. We get people rolling our eyes at us all the time as well. I don't care. We choose to focus otherwise, and don't condemn them for their choice. It's a fun game we play, but the boys know it's just a game = but Leprechauns are real :)
 
We don't celebrate Christmas at all, so definitely no Santa here. It can be tricky, especially around the 4-5 age mark (at least for us). We've just explained to the kids that WE don't believe in Santa but that other kids do, so they can't say things like "there's no such thing as Santa" or "Santa is BAD" to other people.

Yeah and as for the "you're ruining" line...guess what...they can shove it. LOL! I have learned to just ignore remarks like that, and because growing up I didn't celebrate the holidays I got a lot of teasing and stuff...it just rolls off my back.
 
Darcy Baldwin said:
I We celebrate Jesus' birthday on Christmas, and Santa is like a clown you invite to the party to entertain :)

= but Leprechauns are real :)
Click to expand...

LOL Darcy!! Yeah I remember you do the whole leprechaun dust thing!

I guess we did do Santa as a child, but I figured it al out ;pretty soon and just got mad at my parents.

I'm really glas to hear I'm not totally alone!!
 
I try to downplay Santa as much as possible, but my 4 year old still sees stuff about him on TV and at school. I've told him that Santa's just pretend, but he doesn't really seem to get that yet. We, too, try to emphasize that Christmas is about Jesus' birth.
 
I just don't understand people that judge others so harshly.
Are you raising THEIR kids not to believe in Santa or Christmas or Easter etc etc etc? No. So they should just keep quiet. Bah!

Do what you want and screw the rest. LOL! That's how I'm raising my kids. :P
 
We did the Santa thing when we were little, but my parents kind of taught us similar to what Darcy does. Santa was just a fun person that lots of kids believed in, but we were taught that the birth of Jesus was the most important thing this time of year. We also gave goodies away to the neighbors all the time during Christmas. I think that's the part that we loved the most - caroling to the neighbors house and giving them a plate of homemade goodies.

I wouldn't put too much stock into what other people say. You are raising your child the way your conscience dictates and nobody has the right to criticize you for it.
 
I hope people don't throw things at me, but I've always wondered why it's considered OK to lie to our kids "for fun"...again, coming from a background of someone who has NEVER celebrated most holidays. There's Santa, the Easter Bunny, the Tooth Fairy...why is it acceptable to tell kids that these things are real? Doesn't that just bring mistrust into the equation when they realize that they were duped?

(Please don't throw things at me, I mean...you all are entitled to raise your kids however, but this is something I've always wondered about...just like you may have questions about why our religion does things a certain way, I have questions about why those who aren't part of our religion do them the other, lol).
 
As a child raised with Santa and the Easter Bunny and the Tooth Fairy in the equation, I can honestly say that I didn't feel duped or lied to at all when I realized they didn't exist. Neither did my brother or sister. I also think that Santa exists for those pure at heart. My mom calls herself the Head Elf at this time of year even though we all know who's buying gifts for who at this point. It's something fun, and a little silly, and it reminds me of my childhood and that wonder behind Santa and his 8 Reindeer.

Just because you believe in Santa, doesn't mean that the season can't be about Jesus' birth and giving to others and making others happy.
 
Last edited:
It's a legitimate question, Bree!

JP doesn't believe in Santa any more, but he's not upset with anyone over it, nor does his have any distrust for us now. I think most kids just come to a gradual realization that Santa is Mom/Dad/Grandma/some person who loves them, and they accept that the gifts were given in the spirit of love, giving, and kindness. I know that's how JP sees it. He actually said to me, "Santa's kinda like another way to express Jesus' love for us because Jesus was kind, giving and loving too!" Ok, I don't entirely see it that way, but he does have a point to a certain extent.
 
My kids do believe in Santa and I kinda wish they didn't! I don't quite know how to break it to them!
 
I would love to have a Santa-free house, but I know my FI and my mom are way too traditional for that to ever be possible, so my kids will be raised with the traditional Santa story. I will do my best to counter it with a Jesus birthday cake, an interactive nativity, etc.

Bree, I don't know of anyone that grew up with Santa and felt betrayed, lied to, or otherwise. Not that it's not possible, but I just don't know anyone personally. When I found out abt Santa, I was disappointed, to be sure, but I didn't feel put upon or like it was a cruel hoax or something.

Are you a Jehovah's Witness? That's the only religion/faith I know that does not celebrate holidays, but correct me if I'm wrong. I just wanted to share a cute Christmaselated story abt my JW elementary school bus driver if you were. :)
 
LeeAndra said:
Are you a Jehovah's Witness? That's the only religion/faith I know that does not celebrate holidays, but correct me if I'm wrong. I just wanted to share a cute Christmaselated story abt my JW elementary school bus driver if you were. :)
Click to expand...
Yep...both Jae and I are. :)
 
We do Santa but definitely not Jesus, LOL.
Yeah, that's right, I said it, whatcha gonna do? ;)

Sorry, I'm in an ornery mood today.
 
Oh, okay. :)

My cute story:

My mom had purchased some Christmas goose dishtowels (?!) for me to give to my bus driver the last week of school before Christmas break. Unbeknownst to me, she was a JW, so when I gave her the towel set, she told me she couldn't accept them because she didn't celebrate Christmas. I was simultaneously confused and sad, but she quickly told me that if I was giving her the towels as a friendship gift, she could take them then. I happily told her they were a friendship gift, and so she took them. I don't think it even registered enough with me to tell my mom abt it later, but as I got older (and now), I always smile at how nice she was to me. Of course, she couldn't use the towels and prolly threw them away/regifted, but it was sweet of her to take them.
 
Voodoo_Bryn said:
We do Santa but definitely not Jesus, LOL.
Yeah, that's right, I said it, whatcha gonna do? ;)

Sorry, I'm in an ornery mood today.
Click to expand...
For whatever reason, you struck my funny bone and I sprayed water all over the monitor (via my nose). Didn't expect that response, that's for sure! :)
 
We dont.

DH's family didnt do it and him and his sibs never felt like they were missing anything and they never ruined it for other kids. They celebrated Jesus' birthday and made a cake and everything. It is just as magical with out Santa.

I was crushed when I walked out to find my dad putting out Santa presents. And for all of my childhood I thought Christmas And Easter were about Santa and the Easter Bunny. I had no clue it had anything to do with Jesus.

We will teach him that Santa was based on a real person and that he shouldn't spoil other kids fun. We play Santa on Christmas day though. One person wears the santa hat and hands out gifts, but thats as Santa-ish as we get.
 
LeeAndra said:
My mom had purchased some Christmas goose dishtowels (?!) for me to give to my bus driver the last week of school before Christmas break. Unbeknownst to me, she was a JW, so when I gave her the towel set, she told me she couldn't accept them because she didn't celebrate Christmas. I was simultaneously confused and sad, but she quickly told me that if I was giving her the towels as a friendship gift, she could take them then. I happily told her they were a friendship gift, and so she took them. I don't think it even registered enough with me to tell my mom abt it later, but as I got older (and now), I always smile at how nice she was to me. Of course, she couldn't use the towels and prolly threw them away/regifted, but it was sweet of her to take them.
Click to expand...
Awww, that's sweet! It's a hard thing to try to explain, especially to kids. There is a guy at DH's work that gives him a hard time about the "Christmas bonus"...we accept it because it's a gift from the company thanking him for the last year's worth of work (they don't work between Christmas and New Years), but some people figure that's hypocritical, etc. Some people just like to argue, lol.
 
Anyhoo, we do incorporate Santa into Christmas but that SO burns me when people say that crap like "You're ruining Christmas for your kids!" I can't believe the nerve of some people!
 
We have Santa around here (well not anymore since my youngest if now 9 and knows the truth). We also made sure the kids know the real meaning of Christmas. At my ex in-laws, we always got together Christmas Eve. We would sit around and sing carols. She had made up these little cupcake looking things (that she used over and over each year) with a candle in them. We would sing Happy Birthday to Jesus.
 
AnnieBananie said:
I'm curious by nature and like to know more about people... so if I'm prying, ignore me! Why don't you (general "you" for JWs) celebrate holidays?
Click to expand...
LOL, no worries...we're used to the questions and don't mind answering them, lol! :) Each holiday is something different - for Christmas the basic reasons (yes there is more than one) are...

1) Nowhere in the Bible does it say that Dec 25 is the day of Jesus' birth (we do believe in Jesus, contrary to some people's beliefs about us) - in fact the Bible says that the shepherds were out in the fields with their sheep, which they wouldn't have been in December because that is their rainy season

2) Nowhere in the Bible does it say that we should celebrate Jesus' birth - we are only instructed to remember his death.

3) Christmas was actually created by early Christians to coincide with Pagan holidays that already existed - even the Catholic encyclopedia says this

(Sorry if I offend anyone with this post - I don't mean to, I'm just merely stating our beliefs...and I don't mean to hijack this thread, lol).
 
Voodoo_Bryn said:
We do Santa but definitely not Jesus, LOL.
Yeah, that's right, I said it, whatcha gonna do? ;)

Sorry, I'm in an ornery mood today.
Click to expand...
LOL, we don't do Santa OR Jesus.

well used to do Santa but Henry figured it out so I don't have to continue with that charade anymore.
 
ditzyscrap said:
I hope people don't throw things at me, but I've always wondered why it's considered OK to lie to our kids "for fun"...again, coming from a background of someone who has NEVER celebrated most holidays. There's Santa, the Easter Bunny, the Tooth Fairy...why is it acceptable to tell kids that these things are real? Doesn't that just bring mistrust into the equation when they realize that they were duped?

(Please don't throw things at me, I mean...you all are entitled to raise your kids however, but this is something I've always wondered about...just like you may have questions about why our religion does things a certain way, I have questions about why those who aren't part of our religion do them the other, lol).
Click to expand...

I don't feel duped. I still believe in Santa. not the whole fat guy in a red suit thing but Santa to me represents the magic of Christmas, and I believe in that. So I don't feel that I'm lying to my children. :)
 
So what about celebrations/holidays Bree?
One of my best friends was raised JW. I'm not sure if he still follows that faith or not. By the time I met him (I was like 19 or 20, he was 18 or 19) I think he had been criticized so much, he gave up explaining, so we don't really talk about it. I've always been curious though.
 
BrodoNY0123 said:
So what about celebrations/holidays Bree?
One of my best friends was raised JW. I'm not sure if he still follows that faith or not. By the time I met him (I was like 19 or 20, he was 18 or 19) I think he had been criticized so much, he gave up explaining, so we don't really talk about it. I've always been curious though.
Click to expand...

For MOST (if not all, but I can't be sure because I haven't looked at this info for years, not since I was a kid) of the holidays it's basically the same reason as #3 for Christmas - many of the holidays out there were created by Christianity to go with current Pagan holidays and rituals. Easter became about Jesus' death, when it was originally worshipping gods for spring. Valentine's day, St. Patrick's Day, Halloween, even New Years have other meanings behind them. That's the simplified look at it, anyhow.

I did say that we remember Jesus' death each year, and it's "like" Easter, but many times it's not held at the same time - we calculate it based on the actual Jewish calendar (Nisan 14), not based on the more recent/currently used calendar system. It's the ONLY thing that we do each year.

Birthdays for us is tied sorta into #2 of the Christmas one - if we were never told to celebrate Jesus' birth, who was perfect and the most deserving of all humans to be celebrated, why would we celebrate our own births...we were all born in sin and into sin (whereas Jesus was perfect). Besides that the only other times birthdays are mentioned as being celebrated in the Bible (twice), people were killed (John the Baptist was beheaded, and I can't remember the other one now, lol...my memory is getting really bad).

LOL, again...sorry to hijack the thread! :)
 
My husband's family doesn't celebrate Easter or Christmas (or even birhtdays really) and they are Brethren - so he grew up with nothing of that sort.
And while I am sure that December 25th wasn't actually Jesus birthday (probably happened near Passover) so many festivals and feasts were begun in the Old Testament that helped the people remember what God had done. And I know that there were many other festivals around soltice and this time of year but I see Christmas as an opportunity to remember what God has done, celebrate who he is and the gift of Christ and to redeem this day for Him (even if it was previously a day celebrating something else).

It's really interesting hearing what everyone else has to say on this subject! :)

(And I just want to be clear, that I in no way think people need to celebrate the same way as me - this is what fits into the values of our house and what works for us...)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Community platform by XenForo® © 2010-2026 XenForo Ltd.
Back
Top