American Idol (spoilers)

4noisyboys

4noisyboys

New member
WTH? I'm totally shocked. How is everyone else feeling about tonights results?

Two of my family's favorites went home tonight.
 
4noisyboys said:
LOL! Yep, that it does!

I almost feel like I don't want to watch it anymore. I know I will...I still have a few favorites, but honestly...Aaron, Paige, Katie....who the heck voted for them?
Click to expand...

Paige is the current Vote For The Worst pick. Katie and Aaron I imagine are getting the high school/tween vote thanks to the parents who pay for unlimited texting. :p

I really liked Alex, Lilly and Katelyn so this week was definitely a disappointment. :thumbdown:
 
I didn't really like Alex or Lilly... so I'm not really uspet. Though I do think that Paige should have been voted off before both Lilly and Katelynn.
 
I *love* Lilly, so I was pissed. I also couldn't believe that Tim got picked over Alex. I mean come on, Alex is shy..but Tim?? Seriously, they dude cannot carry a tune to save his life. Yuck! I knew Katelyn would be gone after her last weird performance, but I definitely didn't see Lilly being cut over Katie. Also, Paige scares me for some reason. Her eyes just give me the heebies. I thought she'd be gone. Blegh.
 
I was surprised to see Lilly go..I wasn't over the top crazy about her so I'm okay with it..but i was still surprised b/c I actually thought she'd go pretty far. Alex should have stayed...his voice is crazy-good. I thought Andrew should have gone home...yeah he had one good week in Hollywood but since then he's not been that great. I thought his song this week was awful...very weird choice.

and what is up with Crystal...she could have looked a little bit happier when she made it to top 12...is she still sick or something?
 
Last edited:
nikkiARNGwife said:
and what is up with Crystal...she could have looked a little bit happier when she made it to top 12...is she still sick or something?
Click to expand...

I saw that! I think she just didn't feel well..she did crack a small smile. Also on Tuesday after she sang she sat on the amp while being judged....pretty sure she still has some issues going on.
 
Yeah I saw the same thing with Crystal, too. I really hope she's all right - not knowing what was wrong with her last week, it could be she hasn't rested enough with their intense rehearsal schedule. Or it could be she knew there would be someone who was a friend was going home. She did also look a little on the pale side, too...
 
I was so upset. Alex is SO talented - he did not deserve to go home. I also really liked Lilly, and was shocked to see her leave.

I hope Crystal is OK. She didn't look like she was feeling well. :(
 
I was & wasn't shocked. I was waiting for Katelyn to be kicked off, but I was surpised to see her standing next to Paige! Although if Paige was picked for VFTW, then I guess we will be seeing her for awhile.

Todrick I wasn't that surprised, but a little - he actually did really well the other night. I didn't expect him to win or anything. I had picked Alex to go home. He does have a good voice, but he just seems so stiff and shell shocked on stage. He's boring.
 
Aaron, Paige, and Katie should definitely not have made it this far! Of course, I never vote so I guess I can't complain. :) Alex was one of my favs.
 
mlewis said:
Aaron, Paige, and Katie should definitely not have made it this far! Of course, I never vote so I guess I can't complain. :) Alex was one of my favs.
Click to expand...

That's how I feel Melissa. I don't vote, so i really shouldn't complain. We just loved Lilly (well, my two boys that watch (18 & 24) and my dh and me, and we all thought that Alex had an amazing voice. I was really hoping he'd make it and hopefully get more experience.

and yes...Aaron, Paige and Katie need to go right away. I think I might start voting!
 
I think that Crystal is Diabetic, I saw that on Regis and Kelly, so maybe she's out of energy.

I was surprised Alex was gone, I thought it would have been Tim.

I'm not really into any of the girls except Crystal, so that didn't make much difference to me.
 
My two faves are still in - Crystal and Michael.

I was shocked to see Alex leaving over Aaron. Alex also broke my heart when he was crying. It was so sad.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Community platform by XenForo® © 2010-2026 XenForo Ltd.
Back
Top