Wanted to say the same thing: there are people who just aren't that fluent in English and for them it's a major accomplishment to just C+P a comment, so we shouldn't be that hard on them. Even though I prefer the comments with real content, I try hard to appreciate the other ones, too. Simply because someone took the time to open my page, look at it, and even more - leave a comment.
But can I say I'm guilty of having done one comment that said "Beautiful page" recently? (Or something to that extent). I'd actually already planned out all that I was going to say about that page, but sometimes I start with just that general statement. And before I even realized it, I hit the submit button and there it was "Beautiful page" and I'm thinking: "What the H...! Did I just do that?" Forgot on whose page it was, and I didn't want to add another comment (though I seriously thought about that), but felt it was a little embarrassing to add two comments. So, I hope, no one got offended by that comment!
And can I say something very honest and open here? (This is nothing personal, and I really hope no one gets offended by this one!) I do the Layout Lovings sometimes, and there you are obliged to leave comments on other pages, too. No big deal, as I usually really love the pages I see there. But every once in a while I get a page where I sit and sit and can't think of anything that I really like about this page (y'all know, we have different tastes and styles, so it doesn't even mean that it's an ugly page!). So with those kind of pages I do have a hard time giving meaningful comments. And maybe other people think that about my pages - I understand! Can anyone relate?