American Idol: Week 4 Results *CAUTION SPOILERS*

Teresa

Teresa

New member
Results are in on the East Coast- feel free to vent!! :) LOL

Top Vote Getters:

gngabriel 34
FlirtatiousBrat 33
~ashleigh 31
Lilcameronsmommy 30
Teresa Ferguson 28
my4boys 28
kscwgirl 28
ScrapMonkey 27
jorgies5 27
meganmecrazy 27
Kat Stokes 26
Leila 26
Tracyfish 26
Mandy 25
Paula 25
tmcquaid 25
pbumbaca 24
mommy2twins 23
Nettio 23
ditzyscrap 22
MandaBean 20
scarlettcharm 2 (just joined us!)


Week 4 Top Votes:

Mandy 5
ScrapMonkey 5
Nettio 4
MandaBean 3
Kat Stokes 3
pbumbaca 3
my4boys 3
Lilcameronsmommy 3
~ashleigh 3
tmcquaid 3
Tracyfish 3
FlirtatiousBrat 3
Teresa Ferguson 2
Paula 2
Leila 2
ditzyscrap 2
gngabriel 2
kscwgirl 2
jorgies5 2
meganmecrazy 2
mommy2twins 2
scarlettcharm 2
 
Teehee.
I'm a country girl at heart myself but I seriously don't think she was as bad as David.
Guess we'll see next week if she can redeem herself.
 
Well, she didn't do that song any justice but I think she does have an ok voice. I have a feeling David was voted off because of his extracurricular activities before he tried out for Idol. Neither of them would have made it past the top 12 though...
 
I thought Kristie was going home last week, and so this week I thought she sealed the deal. I agree that David's, errr, news may not have helped in the long run, but Kristie's take on country just doesn't feel authentic. It is like she is over doing it, and that bugs me.

WTG gals for getting that right, I was shocked!
 
I thought her song placement was a wreck..and Simon was right..it wasn't the right song for a country spin. David can sing, and so can she, but she's been in my bottom for weeks now. I just don't think she is up there.
 
What did you all think about the whole "stolen" arrangement by David Cook on the Eleanor Rigby song? I thought it was awesome but they are saying he "stole" the way he sang it from a Seattle group. Personally, that doesn't matter to me... I mean they can sing the song in the original form or whatever way they want, right? The gossip shows are trying to make this a big deal but I don't think it matters. What do you all think??
 
I haven't heard that one Julie! I wouldn't think it would matter really. I just don't understand why they are doing Lennon/McCartney AGAIN.
 
ITA, it shouldn't matter about the arrangement. It's not like he claimed it to be HIS original arrangement. They are doing cover songs. I think this happened before (maybe it was Chris Daughtry?). And, if I remember correctly, the following week Ryan credited the arrangement to whomever, and the "scandal" was put to rest. Anyone else remember that, or did I just make it up (never know these days, lol!)?

As for more Lennon/McCartney, I kind of like the idea! I am hoping they are doing that to give them more songs to chose from (I guess the list last week was fairly limited). And maybe this will save us from a week of show tunes down the road. My girls are ALL about the Beatles these days, so they like it, too.
 
thought her song placement was a wreck..and Simon was right..it wasn't the right song for a country spin. David can sing, and so can she, but she's been in my bottom for weeks now. I just don't think she is up there.
Click to expand...

100% agree with ya Manda!
 
It was Chris Daughtry..he sang another version of Walk The Line..then was mentioned the next week in a blib and was over. I think it's insane..nobody said they had to sing a particular arrangement just the song..it's the same song so why does it matter lol
 
Either way, they are singing someone else's arrangement of lyrics and music. Silly to make a fuss over that one.

And honestly, I don't care who stripped where, as long as I don't have to see it. :) Well..unless it's..well..ok I take it back.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Community platform by XenForo® © 2010-2026 XenForo Ltd.
Back
Top