SYTYCD Top 8 Poll
 

Well...this is getting REALLY hard!! What did you think of tonight's performances? Tell me who you think will be the bottom 2 guys, bottom 2 girls, and who is going home!

Evan & Jannette (jazz, rhumba)
Brandon & Jeanine (waltz, pop jazz)
Ade & Melissa (cha-cha, contemporary)
Jason & Kayla (broadway, hip-hop)

Our standings after last week:

Karen - 33
Megan - 31
Aaron - 30
Leila - 25
Crystal - 24
Laura - 24
Bree - 22
Meghan - 21
Jennifer - 17
Lizzy - 16
Shawna - 10
La - 9
Heather - 6
Jenny - 6
Renee - 5
Col - 2
Jessica - 2

I haven't watched all of it...only half, so I will probably be back to change these...

Bottom 2 guys:
Evan and Brandon

Bottom 2 girls:
Melissa and Jeannine

bye Melissa and Evan??

Bottom guys:
Evan & Ade

Bottom girls:
Melissa & Jeanine

Eliminated: Evan & Melissa

I have no idea, lol...I kept changing my mind through the show...you should see the scribbles on my notepad!

Guys: Evan & Brandon
Girls: Melissa & Janette

Eliminated: Melissa & Evan

I hate to put Melissa in the bottom after her contemporary performance...I think it MAY have saved her, but I've gotta go with my gut. I'm not a Melissa fan to be honest, I just really liked that piece.

bottom 2 guys
Evan & Jason

bottom 2 girls
Melissa & Jeanine

going home
Evan & Melissa

Bottom 2 guys
Jason and Evan

Bottom 2 girls
Janette and Jeannine

Going home
Evan and Janette

It's going to be interesting to see who gets into the final. I LOVE Jeanine. LOVE! But I like Janette too. And of course the judges are obsessed with Kayla (personally not a fan at all).

I LOVE Evan. He's just so freaking cute. But I think he'll be going home too. He's just not on the same level as the other 3.

Bottom guys:
Evan & Jason

Bottom girls:
Melissa & Jeanine

Eliminated: Evan & Melissa

Evan/Ade, Melissa/Jeannine

Evan/Melissa

bottom guys: evan and brandon
bottom girls: janette and melissa
goodbye: evan and melissa

I think it may be Evan's time to go home, but I love him. I keep thinking about his brother that has already made it to Vegas for next season (and almost made it this season). Ryan choreographs all Evan's solos, and I think he could really be amazing.... so I've already transferred my hope to Ryan for next season's winner.

Yeah, I loved both of the brothers...Evan is just so stinkin' adorable!! :) Ryan is a sweetheart too, though...

I wonder if America will keep Evan going through...he'll be like the Clay Aiken of SYTYCD, lol...getting by not by his talent alone but personality...

i'm not really in on this poll...but i defenitely agree with everyone's picks for who should go home. evan's a doll, but he's pretty much only good in his own style. and if melissa bites her finger in that 'naughty ballerina' way that she likes to do so much ever again, i might have to fly to california just to cut that dang finger off...that being said - i loved the contemporary number her and ade did! the pop jazz was great too. okay - there's my 2 cents!

Bottom guys:
Evan & Ade

Bottom girls:
Melissa & Jeanine

Eliminated: Evan & Melissa :(

ACK! I didn't get here in time to vote! :(

I for real sucked!! I am quite ticked off about Evan not being in the bottom. :( He's such a sweet guy, but he is def. the worst one left. :(

annoyed at evan too....blah

am I the only one that had Melissa safe? lol

ACK! I'm not able to even watch...someone tell me what's going on!!! LOL!

I don't think ANYone saw that coming! I'm sad now :(

It was a surprising night..but my faves are still there...so I think I will be ok. I am just bummed that Jason had to go before Evan. :(

YOU ARE KIDDING ME :( I'm so sad. I don't even want to watch.

Yes Megan...It was sad! And it was Janette and Kayla and Janette went home. Brandon was the other guy. :(

Was this show some kind of joke??? OMG! I guess I will watch it tomorrow but I'm not going to be happy. I do want to see the performances they were talking about for their 100 anniversary!

what the eff just happened tonight????? and p.s. - that katie holmes routine was taped?? LAME!

ITA!!! :thumbdown: At first I tried to convince hubby that she was there and the audience was just REALLY quiet. :p

That was the worst results show EVER!! Well, I mean...the performances were good and all, but the results themselves sucked...America sooo got it wrong!!

And yeah, the Katie Holmes thing...weird. I was wondering what was up when she was wearing the same outfit in the little intro thingie as when they first talked to her, but she was saying she was there "today" to dance and sing. It didn't quite add up until I saw the performance, lol.

Standings after tonight's completely whacked results:

Karen - 34
Aaron - 32
Megan - 31
Crystal - 26
Laura - 26
Leila - 26
Meghan - 25
Bree - 24
Jennifer - 19
Lizzy - 18
Shawna - 10
La - 9
Heather - 6
Jenny - 6
Renee - 5
Col - 2
Jessica - 2

Yeah..the Katie Holmes thing was totally LAME-O. ugh! It was seriously such a weird night!

Evan clearly has a huge fan base. I personally think they've been giving him really bad styles of dance in hopes that the fan base will fade because he's no good at ballroom, but it's not working. They might as well recognize that he's a favorite and give him something he can do, and do well. I would be sad that Jason went before Evan, but Jason was in the bottom several times before they even hit the top 10. He was struggling, then he had that dance last week choreographed by Travis, and things looked better for him.

All the "100th show" routines were taped, except the opening final 8 number. Travis tweeted about it a couple of weeks ago. Katie Holmes was taped a very long time ago (and sucked, imo... she wasn't dancing, those guys were dancing around her). They do usually tape stuff for the results show -- at the very least it's shot out of order, the group opening dance and the musical guest are shot before they go live, then they insert the taped pieces into the show.

If you want to get real picky, the whole thing we see Wednesday night is taped on Tuesday. I get up on Wednesdays and go read the spoilers from people who attended the taping. Apparently this past week the judges were very hard on Evan (almost mean) and what we saw on TV was quite edited. Interesting, no?