I figure'd that if you'd thought about it, there would be good reasons for not doing it! Those are good reasons. Thank you Robin for taking the time to explain your thinking!
I agree about the honest comments thing -- I wouldn't want to see a bunch of "great page" comments copied ad nauseum. But isn't that the same issue with a "praise game" which makes you comment on particular layouts that you might not ordinarily select out of the gallery for praise? I think people love getting praise and just having someone acknowledge that their layouts have been looked at and appreciated somehow.
There are so many of us who aspire to leave comments but there are so many other things going on that we don't do it as much as we should. It would be great to have a "push" in that direction sometimes and it would be great to brainstorm ways to get more people taking the time to leave thoughtful comments.
I'm not arguing, just thinking out loud.
