American Idol discussion thread

[Paula]

Ok, didn't Allison look AWESOME tonight!? I loved her hair!! She sounded fabbo!!

Also, I can't believe Haeley is still there! Ugga! And WTH about Jermaine? He's still there? Geez, I am shocked.

[jessica31876]

Ughh I missed it tonight. I thought it was on at 9. So who all got voted off? Who was in the bottom 3 or 4 (not sure how many there are in the first few shows). I know I personally voted like at least 15 times for Casey LOL

[Paula]

For the girls, it was Ashley and Janell
For the boys, it was Joe and Tyler

[haydensmommy217]

I voted 275 times for Casey lol got to love unlimited texting. Haley should've left tonight.

[~Julie~]

I did really bad with my guesses. I am shocked that Haeley is still there and Jermaine too.

[jessica31876]

ohh I really liked Tyler

[Paula]

Me too Julie. I can't believe that Joe is gone and Jermaine is still there. WTH! LOL

[jessica31876]

LOL Yea defenitely love unlimited texts...I would have voted more but I was using my daughters cell phone to vote and she was getting texts in between my votes so I could not vote as much as I wanted to. My cell phone does not have unlimited texting.

Originally Posted by haydensmommy217

I voted 275 times for Casey lol got to love unlimited texting. Haley should've left tonight.

[scrapmonkey]

I was surprised that Tyler was voted off rather than Alex - I thought Alex just looked like a scared kid being told sing or face a literal firing squad - I've seen very few performances as nervous as that one on AI once they get through to the top 24. I think I was half waiting to see partially wet pants at the end of his performance.
I was not surprised to see Ashley go (just expected Lacey to go before her), and I thought Janell would go, so the girls weren't a surprise. But the boys were surprises - I actually could listen to their two performances, but there were ones that stayed that were brutal to listen to.
I must say, I really enjoyed their group performance - they sounded better together as a group than as individuals.

[dana]

ackkk - i was totally surprised by all those ... i ALMOST thought joe would leave - but i thought jermaine would go before him for sure ....

[scrapperjade]

None of my picks were even close - I sat there with my mouth gaping open, lol! What the HECK about Lacey not going??? She BUTCHERED her song. And don't even get me started on Haeley. I wasn't really surprised about Tyler, while I like him - he wasn't that strong last night. I was screaming at the screen when Joe got booted over Tim though... I couldn't believe it!!

You guys need to vote better, lol!

[meganmecrazy]

I wasn't really surprised by the ones that went home. During the show I jotted down who I LOVED and then the ones that I didn't like. I totally picked the wrong ones from my do-not-like list which included the ones that went home. Except Tyler, I didn't have him written down at all. LOL! It was harder to pick the guys than the girls. because there were 5 girls that I just didn't care for. The guys, although they didn't blow me away with anything it was just harder to pick.

[sarahbhb]

Oh Megan, that's so smart to jot those down as you watch...I was relying on the little clips that they do at the end of the show (it's amazing that within two hours you can already totally forget about someone). I almost picked Tyler as one I thought might be going home but I think I decided not to out of hope that he wouldn't. I do really like him but his performance this week was not good.

[Leila]

I'm not surprised that Haeley is still there. She is VFTW's pick for now, along with Tim Urban. I even said as much in the vote thread. Of course, I was totally wrong in my actually guesses too!!

[nikkiARNGwife]

Originally Posted by Leila

I'm not surprised that Haeley is still there. She is VFTW's pick for now, along with Tim Urban. I even said as much in the vote thread. Of course, I was totally wrong in my actually guesses too!!

I was afraid of this...I really wanted her to go home b/c she is so annoying..but really at this stage I don't care who goes home (as long as it's none of my faves lol)

Tyler surprised me a little, but I totally got the same vibe the judges did when he was performing..like he was just trying TOO hard with the 70's thing...if you think back to Bo Bice..that was just who he was...an old school kind of rocker.